Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
15 Years
experience
Your Staffing Solution Partner in Western New York
Selective Staffing Solutions is a full-service WBE Certified Woman-Owned staffing and talent acquisition firm based in Williamsville, NY. Since 2011, we have specialized in connecting top local talent with businesses across Western New York, serving industries ranging from healthcare to information technology. Our approach emphasizes personalized attention, with recruiters who deeply understand both candidate aspirations and employer needs to ensure optimal matches.

As a locally owned business, we combine market expertise with a commitment to confidentiality and support throughout the hiring process. Our team maintains strong regional connections and offers tailored solutions for temporary, temporary-to-hire, and executive search placements. With a proven track record of delivering quality candidates and maintaining 24-hour response times, we serve as strategic partners for organizations seeking to build effective teams.
Services
Temporary Staffing Executive Search Direct Hire Placement Payroll Services Contingent Workforce Solutions Temporary-to-Hire Programs
Details
  • Year established: 2011
Highlights and features
  • We deliver candidates with 24-hour response times
  • Our recruiters maintain deep Western New York market knowledge
  • Personalized approach to candidate screening and placement
  • Proven track record since 2011 with 98% client satisfaction
  • Specialized teams for industry-specific staffing requirements
Associations and certifications
  • WBE Certified
What people say
Screened professionally Prompt and efficient Best in class service Quality candidates Excellent communication
Services
Temporary Staffing
Our temporary staffing solutions provide businesses with flexible workforce options while maintaining quality standards. We handle payroll, benefits, and HR responsibilities while connecting employers with pre-screened professionals across multiple industries. Clients benefit from reduced administrative burdens and immediate access to qualified candidates for short-term needs.
Executive Search
Through our Alberts Executive Search division, we specialize in identifying C-suite and senior-level talent for Western New York organizations. Our process combines industry expertise with targeted outreach to find leaders who match both technical requirements and company culture. Clients receive curated candidate pools with detailed assessments and interview preparation.
Direct Hire Placement
We facilitate direct hire placements by thoroughly vetting candidates through skills assessments, reference checks, and cultural fit evaluations. Our process reduces time-to-hire while ensuring quality through access to a diverse talent pool. Employers receive comprehensive candidate profiles with salary negotiation guidance and onboarding support.
Payroll Services
Our payroll services simplify workforce management by handling tax filings, wage disbursements, and benefits administration. Businesses gain access to cloud-based HR tools while maintaining compliance with state and federal regulations. Clients receive dedicated support for payroll processing, workers' compensation, and employment law compliance.
Contingent Workforce
We help companies build scalable workforce solutions through contingent staffing programs. Our system provides consistent access to qualified professionals with customizable engagement terms. Employers benefit from reduced overhead costs while maintaining workforce flexibility through our comprehensive talent management framework.
Questions
What industries do you specialize in?
We serve Western New York employers across multiple sectors including healthcare, finance, manufacturing, IT, and professional services through our specialized staffing divisions.
How quickly can you fill staffing needs?
Our typical response time is 24 hours or less, with many clients receiving qualified candidate matches within one business day of submitting requests.
Do you offer executive search services?
Yes, through our Alberts Executive Search division we specialize in leadership placements for C-suite, director-level, and senior management positions.
What makes your staffing approach different?
We focus on cultural fit and long-term success by thoroughly understanding both employer needs and candidate career goals before making placements.
Do you work with small businesses?
Yes, we provide customized staffing solutions for businesses of all sizes from startups to Fortune 500 companies in the Western New York region.
How do you screen candidates?
Our screening process includes skills assessments, reference checks, and behavioral interviews to ensure technical competence and cultural compatibility with client organizations.
Reviews (7)
Mike Lombard
May 05, 2022 Report
Kim at Selective Staffing Solutions was a great help to me with setting up interviews and answering questions. Lost a job 2 weeks ago and got a job within a week and a half with Kim's help. Thank you very much for all your did!
Michael Nickerson
Apr 23, 2022 Report
The company contacted me shortly after I posted on Ziprecruiter and worked quickly to provide employment options and kept me involved in the search process. This was the fasting hiring process I have experienced.
Josh Shamenda
Apr 18, 2022 Report
Love love love this agency, Stefanie Buckland is amazing! She goes above and beyond to get you the best job possible, if I can rate this higher than 5stars I honestly would!
Kaci Szczygiel
Dec 17, 2021 Report
Working for Selective Staffing Solutions has been such a positive experience. I have been able to learn so much, grow professionally and help so many people find new jobs that are growing into careers. I am forever thankful for SSS!
Nick Rawda
Dec 16, 2021 Report
Kim and Thom were excellent help through the process of me getting my current job! They were very supportive all the way through. They were able to set me up for success and I would highly recommend this company for anyone in search of a job.
Angela C.
Dec 12, 2021 Report
Worst temporary agency I have ever dealt with. So completely unprofessional, I don't know if it's common practice for their employees to not be helping to keep you employed, But working with them I was under the impression that they would find you a job and help you keep said job. That however does not seem to be the case as I recently worked with them took a position. Then after I was working there for about 2 weeks they kept asking about how it was going.

So I told them I was a little nervous because people kept quitting all around me. Also the boss told me I can switch my hours at my interview after I was trained, which ended up not being true, however I was sticking with it and enjoying the job, but the girl at selective staffing chose to go back to my employer and relay everything that I had said to her. Which then caused them to let me go, so don't waste your time using them if you would like to find a job that is lasting.
Natasha P.
May 28, 2021 Report
I highly recommend Selective Staffing. Stefanie has assisted me during the beginning of the pandemic. The entire staff is very professional. I received more job opportunities from this agency than the others. This agency also landed me in the law industry and today I am still working at a law firm with my own office. Try Selective Staffing Solutions TODAY you never know the path and direction this agency can lead you towards.